Skip to content

How Can You Tell If SEO Is Working?

Our clients and prospective clients frequently ask us, “How Can You Tell If SEO Is Working?” While this is an incredibly important topic, it is hard to provide a comprehensive answer right on the spot. In today’s digital landscape, search engine optimization (SEO) plays a crucial role in driving organic traffic and growing your business online. By effectively measuring SEO success, you can track the progress of your efforts, optimize your strategies, and achieve your business goals. Together, we will address the most pressing questions business owners have about measuring SEO success and provide actionable insights to thrive in the competitive online market.

What is SEO and Why Measure SEO Success?

Before diving into the details of measuring how you can tell if SEO is working for your website, let’s briefly understand what SEO is and why it’s important to measure its success. SEO refers to the process of optimizing your website and its content to rank higher in search engine results pages (SERPs). Measuring SEO success allows you to assess the effectiveness of your strategies, identify areas for improvement, and track the return on investment (ROI) of your SEO efforts. There are multiple types of SEO such as Local SEO, On-Page SEO, Technical SEO, and more. For the context of this reading, we will focus primarily on the On-Page factors.

What are the Most Important SEO Metrics to Track?

To gauge the effectiveness of your SEO efforts, it’s essential to monitor key metrics that reflect your website’s visibility, user engagement, and conversions. Here are nine of the most important SEO metrics and why you should care about each of them:

1. Keyword Rankings

Tracking your website’s rankings for relevant keywords in SERPs is crucial. Higher rankings signify improved visibility and increased organic traffic.

2. Organic Traffic

Monitoring the number of visitors coming to your website through organic search is a fundamental SEO metric. An upward trend indicates your SEO strategies are driving more targeted traffic.

3. Engaged Sessions

Engaged sessions measure how visitors interact with your website, considering factors such as time on page, pages per session, and other engagement metrics. This metric helps determine the quality of user experience and content relevance.

4. Conversion Rate

Conversion rate represents the percentage of website visitors who complete a desired action, such as making a purchase, filling out a form, or subscribing to a newsletter. It indicates the effectiveness of your website in generating leads or sales.

5. Domain Authority

Domain authority is a metric that reflects the credibility and trustworthiness of your website in search engines’ eyes. A higher domain authority can positively impact your search rankings.

Backlinks are links from other websites to your site, and they are vital for SEO success. Tracking the quality and quantity of backlinks helps evaluate your site’s authority and visibility.

7. Social Media Engagement

Monitoring social media engagement, including likes, shares, comments, and brand mentions, can provide insights into how well your content resonates with your audience and expands your online reach.

8. Brand Mentions

Keeping track of how often your brand is mentioned online helps you assess its visibility and reputation. Mentions on social media, news articles, blogs, and other platforms contribute to your overall SEO performance.

9. SERP Visibility

Measuring your website’s presence in SERPs for target keywords helps you evaluate the effectiveness of your SEO efforts in gaining visibility among your target audience.

How Do I Set Realistic SEO Goals?

Setting realistic and achievable SEO goals is crucial for measuring success and staying motivated. Goals are an incredibly easy way for you to tell if SEO is working because it helps you understand where you’ve come from and where you want to end up. Here are practical steps to establish meaningful SEO goals:

Understand Your Business Objectives: Align your SEO goals with your overall business objectives, such as increasing sales, generating leads, or expanding your online presence.

Conduct Keyword Research: Identify relevant keywords that align with your services and target audience’s search intent. Incorporate these keywords into your SEO goals to improve rankings and visibility.

Define Measurable Metrics: Ensure your goals are measurable by selecting specific metrics like keyword rankings, organic traffic growth, or conversion rate improvements. This allows you to track progress accurately.

Set Attainable Milestones: Break down your SEO goals into smaller milestones or targets. This approach makes them more achievable and helps you stay motivated throughout the optimization journey.

Setting realistic SEO goals is crucial for several reasons.

Manage Expectations

Realistic goals help business owners manage their expectations regarding the timeline and outcomes of their SEO efforts. SEO is a long-term strategy, and expecting instant results can lead to frustration and disappointment. We ALWAYS try to set proper expectations up front so that when the time comes for the client to ask, “how can I tell if SEO is working”, we can remind them of what we have previously discussed, as well as help them see the trajectory of our efforts together. Setting realistic goals ensures that business owners have a clear understanding of the time and effort required to achieve desired outcomes.

Focus Resources

Setting specific and achievable SEO goals helps business owners allocate their resources effectively. By identifying the areas that need improvement and setting goals around those areas, resources can be directed towards activities that have the greatest impact on SEO performance. This avoids wasting time and effort on ineffective strategies or chasing unrealistic objectives.

Measure Progress

Realistic goals provide a benchmark for measuring progress and success. They allow business owners to track their SEO performance against predetermined objectives and determine whether their efforts are moving them in the right direction. Measuring progress helps identify areas of improvement, celebrate milestones, and make data-driven decisions to optimize strategies.

Optimize Strategy

Realistic goals provide insights into the effectiveness of SEO strategies. When goals are achieved, it indicates that the strategies implemented are working well. Conversely, if goals are not met, it signals the need to reassess and adjust the SEO approach. Setting realistic goals enables business owners to identify gaps, refine tactics, and optimize their overall SEO strategy for better results.

Justify Investments

Realistic SEO goals are essential for justifying investments in SEO. Business owners need to understand the ROI of their SEO efforts and demonstrate the value to stakeholders. By setting goals aligned with business objectives, they can evaluate the impact of SEO on metrics such as traffic, conversions, and revenue. This data-driven approach helps build confidence in SEO investments and secure continued support.

In summary, setting realistic SEO goals helps business owners manage expectations, focus resources, measure progress, optimize strategies, justify investments, and help them see how SEO is working. By establishing achievable objectives, they can navigate the SEO landscape with clarity, make informed decisions, and drive long-term success for their businesses.

What Are The Best SEO Tools for Tracking Metrics?

To effectively measure SEO success, utilizing the right tools is essential. SEO tools can help you gain valuable insights into your website’s performance, track important metrics, and make data-driven decisions to improve your SEO strategy. Here are some top SEO tools that can assist you in tracking and analyzing important metrics:

Google Analytics: A powerful and free tool that provides comprehensive website analytics, including traffic sources, user behavior, and conversions.

SEMrush: An all-in-one SEO toolkit offering keyword research, competitor analysis, and comprehensive SEO reporting to monitor your website’s performance.

Ahrefs: A popular SEO tool known for its robust backlink analysis capabilities, competitive research, and keyword tracking.

Moz: Moz offers a range of SEO tools, including site audits, rank tracking, and link analysis, to optimize your website and monitor its performance.

Google Search Console (GSC): A free tool provided by Google that offers insights into your website’s performance in Google search results, including keyword data and click-through rates.

Ubersuggest: Ubersuggest is a comprehensive SEO tool that provides keyword research, competitor analysis, and content ideas. It offers valuable insights to help optimize your website’s SEO performance.

Common SEO Mistakes That Can Lead to Inaccurate Metrics

While measuring SEO success is crucial, it’s essential to avoid common mistakes that can skew your metrics. Here are some pitfalls to watch out for:

1. Incorrect Tracking Setup: Ensure that your tracking tools, such as Google Analytics, are properly installed and configured to accurately capture data. For example, Universal Analytics was just recently retired as of July 1, 2023. That means that your current Google Analytics should be Google Analytics 4 – otherwise known and referred to as GA4.

2. Inconsistent Reporting Intervals: Maintain consistent reporting intervals to effectively track progress over time. Irregular or sporadic reporting can lead to inaccurate assessments of SEO performance. Consistency is key and will prove to be one of your best friends along the way.

3. Failure to Account for Seasonality: Consider seasonal variations in your industry when analyzing metrics. Comparing data from different seasons can provide a more accurate understanding of performance. A super simple way to check this using a free tool is to use Google Trends and type in the keywords that you rank for, want to rank for, or keywords that are popular in your industry.

4. Ignoring Algorithm Updates: Search engine algorithms evolve, and failure to adapt your strategies to algorithm updates can lead to inaccurate metrics. Stay informed and adjust your SEO tactics accordingly. This is probably the most common and important reason for you to consider hiring an agency like us.

Avoiding these common mistakes will help you ensure the accuracy and reliability of your SEO metrics, enabling you to make data-driven decisions that drive your business forward.

How Do I Interpret My SEO Metrics?

Interpreting your SEO metrics correctly is crucial for actionable insights and decision-making. Consider the following tips when analyzing your data:

1. Context is Key: Understand the context behind the metrics by analyzing trends, comparing them to industry benchmarks, and identifying patterns over time.

2. Identify Correlations: Look for correlations between different metrics. For example, an increase in organic traffic alongside improved keyword rankings can indicate successful optimization efforts.

3. Focus on Goals: Evaluate your metrics in the context of your defined SEO goals. Are you moving closer to achieving those goals? Adjust your strategies based on the insights gained.

How Often Should You Review Your SEO Metrics?

Regularly reviewing and monitoring your SEO metrics is essential for assessing progress and making informed decisions. The frequency of review may vary depending on your business and the dynamics of your website. Consider the following factors:

1. Goals and Objectives: If you have specific short-term goals or campaigns, frequent monitoring may be necessary to track their effectiveness.

2. Industry Dynamics: Industries with rapid changes or intense competition may require more frequent reviews to stay ahead.

3. Resource Availability: Ensure you have the resources and capacity to review metrics regularly without compromising other important tasks.

How Can You Tell If SEO Is Working?

Measuring the success of your SEO efforts is essential to determine whether your strategies are effective and producing desired results. While SEO is a long-term process, there are several key indicators that can help you assess whether your SEO is working. Let’s dive into the details of how you can tell if your SEO is working:

1. Keyword Rankings:

One of the primary indicators of SEO success is an improvement in keyword rankings. By monitoring the positions of your target keywords in search engine results pages (SERPs), you can gauge the visibility and organic reach of your website. If you notice that your rankings are consistently improving over time, it is a positive sign that your SEO efforts are working.

2. Organic Traffic:

A significant increase in organic traffic is another clear indication of successful SEO. Analyze the trends in your website’s organic traffic over time using tools like Google Analytics. If you observe a consistent upward trend in organic traffic, it signifies that your website is attracting more visitors from search engines, indicating the effectiveness of your SEO strategies.

3. Engagement Metrics:

Measuring engagement metrics such as time on page (now known as engagement time in GA4), engaged sessions, or engagement rate provides insights into the quality and relevance of your website’s content. A decrease in engagement rate and an increase in time on page indicate that visitors are finding your content valuable and engaging. This suggests that your SEO efforts are driving targeted traffic and meeting users’ expectations. While these aren’t directly tied to your search rank, they are good indicators of the user experience on your site which can be influenced by SEO.

4. Conversion Rate:

The ultimate goal of SEO is not just to drive traffic but also to convert visitors into customers or leads. Monitoring your website’s conversion rate allows you to evaluate the effectiveness of your SEO strategies in generating desired actions, such as purchases, form submissions, or newsletter sign-ups. An upward trend in conversion rate indicates that your SEO efforts are attracting qualified traffic and encouraging visitors to take the desired actions.

5. Backlinks:

Backlinks from authoritative AND relevant websites are crucial for SEO success. By tracking the acquisition of high-quality backlinks, you can assess the effectiveness of your link building efforts. A steady increase in the number and quality of backlinks indicates that your content is being recognized and valued by others, enhancing your website’s authority and search engine rankings.

6. Social Media Engagement:

Social media can play a significant role in amplifying your SEO efforts. Monitoring social media engagement metrics, such as likes, shares, comments, and brand mentions, provides insights into how well your content resonates with your audience and expands your online reach. An increase in social media engagement signifies that your content is being shared and appreciated, contributing to improved visibility and potential SEO benefits. SEO benefits could come from creating content on your site that expands on what you posted on social media. Because you know that people like the content and are engaging with it, now you can drive some of that attention to your website.

7. SERP Visibility:

A key objective of SEO is to increase your website’s visibility in search engine results pages (SERPs). Regularly checking your website’s presence in SERPs for target keywords allows you to gauge the effectiveness of your SEO strategies. If you observe an increase in the frequency of your website appearing in relevant search results, it indicates improved visibility and a positive impact on organic traffic. Having Google Search Console (GSC) set up will make this process much easier because you can see exactly what search results you are showing up for. Not to mention that GSC is free!

8. Competitor Analysis:

Comparing your SEO performance to that of your competitors provides valuable insights into the effectiveness of your strategies. Analyze the performance of your competitors in terms of keyword rankings, organic traffic, engagement metrics, and backlinks. If you consistently outperform your competitors in these areas, it suggests that your SEO efforts are paying off.

Remember that SEO is an ongoing, long-term process, and it takes time to see significant results. It’s important to analyze these metrics over a reasonable timeframe and consider the industry dynamics and seasonality factors that may influence the results. By regularly monitoring these key indicators and observing positive trends, you can confidently determine that your SEO strategies are working effectively and driving your business towards online success.

How to Improve Your SEO Metrics

Optimizing your SEO metrics requires continuous effort and strategic adjustments. Here are some actionable tips to enhance your SEO performance:

1. Content Optimization: Create high-quality, relevant content that meets users’ search intent. Incorporate target keywords naturally, optimize meta tags, and improve readability.

2. Link Building: Earn high-quality backlinks from authoritative websites in your industry. Focus on building relationships, creating compelling content, and leveraging guest posting opportunities.

3. Mobile Optimization: Ensure your website is mobile-friendly and offers a seamless user experience across various devices. Mobile optimization is crucial for both user satisfaction and search engine rankings.

4. Technical SEO Audit: Regularly conduct a comprehensive technical SEO audit to identify and fix issues that may impact your website’s performance, such as broken links, page load speed, and crawlability.

How to Measure the ROI of Your SEO Efforts

Measuring the return on investment (ROI) of your SEO efforts is essential to justify resources and optimize strategies. Consider the following approaches:

1. Goal Tracking: Set up goal tracking in Google Analytics to measure conversions and assign a monetary value to each conversion. This allows you to quantify the impact of SEO on your business. Some conversions that can be tracked include newsletter sign ups, contact form submissions, phone calls from links on the website, emails from links on the website, online orders, and more.

2. Cost Savings: Calculate the cost savings from organic traffic compared to paid advertising. Determine how much you would have spent on advertising to achieve similar results.

3. Cost per Acquisition (CPA):

Calculate the cost per acquisition by dividing the total cost of your SEO efforts by the number of conversions or acquisitions generated through organic search. This provides a clear understanding of the cost-effectiveness of your SEO campaigns and helps compare it with other marketing channels.

4. Lifetime Value (LTV):

Consider the lifetime value of a customer when evaluating the ROI of your SEO efforts. Determine the average revenue generated from a customer over their lifetime with your business. By comparing this value with the cost of acquiring that customer through SEO, you can assess the long-term profitability and return on investment.

5. Organic Search Traffic Value:

Assign a monetary value to your organic search traffic by estimating the average conversion rate and the average value per conversion. Multiply the number of conversions generated through organic search by the average value per conversion to calculate the estimated value of your organic search traffic. Compare this value with the cost of your SEO efforts to assess the ROI.

It’s important to note that calculating ROI from SEO may involve some estimation and attribution modeling due to the complex nature of online marketing. It’s recommended to use a combination of these methods and adapt them to your specific business goals and circumstances. Regularly reviewing and analyzing these metrics will provide a clearer understanding of the overall ROI from your SEO efforts and guide future optimizations.

How to Compare Your SEO Performance to Competitors

Benchmarking your SEO performance against competitors provides valuable insights and helps identify areas for improvement. Here’s how to compare your SEO performance effectively:

1. Competitor Analysis: Identify your main competitors and analyze their SEO strategies, keyword rankings, backlinks, and social media presence. Tools like SEMrush and Ahrefs can assist in competitor research.

2. Key Metrics Comparison: Compare key metrics, such as organic traffic, keyword rankings, domain authority, and social media engagement, to assess your position relative to competitors.

Final Thoughts

So, back to our original question, “How can you tell if SEO is working”? Measuring SEO success is vital for business owners looking to grow their online presence. By tracking the right metrics, setting realistic goals, leveraging powerful SEO tools, avoiding common mistakes, and interpreting data accurately, you can optimize your strategies, boost visibility, and drive more targeted traffic to your website. Remember, SEO is an ongoing process – a long term effort for organic growth – that requires continuous monitoring, refinement, and adaptation to stay ahead in the dynamic digital landscape. Implement the insights shared in this guide to measure your SEO success effectively and achieve long-term business growth.

Don’t miss out on our weekly newsletter and monthly promos.